We've had both hard and roller covers and prefer the hard type. It lifts with the rear hatch and so makes access to your stuff a little easier. I think the Lincoln one is fairly thick so should provide sound isolation to the cabin.My 2021 Corsair didn't come with a cargo cover. I used them on all my other SUVs. I was so glad that I didn't just 'off the cuff' order one! I wouldn't have liked/used a hard nonretractabke cover! So glad I read about this on the forum!